Some Questions

Tinkerers Anonymous: Some people can't help making changes to "fix" Toki Pona. This is a playground for their ideas.
Tokiponidistoj: Iuj homoj nepre volas fari ŝanĝojn por "ripari" Tokiponon. Jen ludejo por iliaj ideoj.
jan Atijan
Posts: 7
Joined: Mon Oct 05, 2009 8:07 pm

Some Questions

Postby jan Atijan » Fri Apr 30, 2010 2:18 am

I regularly use tp to write stories and stuff (don't worry jan Sonja, I'm not making no money lol.), and I keep running into problems expressing certain concepts clearly. I've been making do with "wita" for life/live/living/opposite of moli, but I know Spanish isn't even mentioned in the etymology section. There any better way to express the concept, without resorting to moli ali? Maybe kon for breathing? I don't know. I've also found myself with a need for some semi-efficient way to express basic shapes like square and triangle. I've been using "leko" from the "nimi moli" section of jan Pije's website for square/block, and "Piwe" for triangle or pyramid. As with life, there's got to be a better way, though... I keep finding myself stuck with expressing the idea of "God" or "spirit" or "supernatural being" as well. I used to use "jan sewi" until I realized that could also mean alien, prophet, astronomer, astrologer, priest, and saint, though, and context only helps in a few cases. Is there some way I could express these ideas in a somewhat clear manner, without referring to them as gases (kon)? Any ideas with any of these dilemmas would be appreciated.

p.s. Two more random questions: When is the book finally coming out, and what exactly does "pu" mean?
There are two kinds of people in the world: Those who think there are only two kinds of people, and those who know there are more than just two.

User avatar
jan Ote
Posts: 424
Joined: Thu Oct 08, 2009 1:15 am
Location: ma Posuka

Re: Some Questions

Postby jan Ote » Fri Apr 30, 2010 8:48 am

jan Atijan, o toki!
Glad to hear you write stories in tp. I hope one day we could read them.
There is no one established way to express "life". The tokiponian philosophy says: what do you really mean by "life"? It depends:
ali li pona. = everything (that I experience) is good, life is good
tenpo mi ali la... = all my time, all my life...
kala li lon telo = fish exists/is in water, fish lives in water
Sometimes you may want to connect life with breathing, sometimes it's not a very good idea. A context and intented meaning is very important.

Posts: 1545
Joined: Wed Dec 02, 2009 12:21 pm
Location: Takoma Park, MD

Re: Some Questions

Postby janMato » Fri Apr 30, 2010 9:50 am

I second jan Ote. Sometimes, but not always you can rephrase it to avoid dealing with the concept lexically. For example, adding "jan li tawa" will imply that the agent is still alive without specifically saying "to live"

If jan Sonja disappeared, and it was up to the community to carry on, I'd be more willing to follow an overload of an existing word than a new base word. e.g. li pan/to live. This sort of innovation, in my opinion is already happening.

If you have to use a loan word, then there is huge loophole, namely proper modifiers. lon Wita, (existence of the "living" sort") tawa Wita (motion of the "living sort"

Only proper modifiers are an open lexical category in toki pona. All other categories are closed, just like I can't invent a new English preposition or pronoun, although in english I'm free to verb a noun or coin a new noun or acronym.

I think the license on toki pona says, don't write a for-sale toki pona guide that competes with the book she's planning to write. The anarchist punk band Pischimo in Russia played a concert in Russia-- I presume tickets were sold--and jan Sonja said she thought that sort of usage was fine (IM conversation long, long ago). Speaking of the book, follow the wikipedia recent changes RSS feed-- at the moment it is the best measure of how much time Sonja is spending on toki pona-- jan Sonja has a real job now and tends to only work on toki pona on weekend and late at night.

And please publish, preferably under the same or more liberal license than the one jan Sonja uses (creative commons)-- amateur linguists like myself need as much toki pona text in the corpus as possible for answering questions like, what usages has the community decided are legal, what usages are happening spontaneously, which rules are the community ignoring, etc.

The most official looking scrap of information says "pu" works like a comma. If this is true about commas, then "pu" is some sort of introduction to a clause. Commas have other uses (written symbols of a verbal pause, splitting enumerated items, etc-- but those are rather useless applications for a word) I have proposed that "pu" introduces a verb phrase that modifies a noun, in the same way that "pi" introduces a noun phrase that modifies a noun. jan Kipo doesn't like the idea at all-- so far the only other legal alternative I can think of is "pi tawa", as in jan moli= dead man (stative) jan pi tawa moli (killing, dying man). A "pu" solution would be jan pu moli- dying man, jan pu moli e jan (killing man).

There are other theories about what it means, posted elsewhere.

Return to “jan nasa li wile ante e toki pona”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest